• Titon Slamet Kurnia
Keywords: Constitutional Court, Election, Theoretical Reflection


The Constitution of Indonesia (UUD NRI 1945) confers authority to the Constitutional Court to decide disputes on the results of general elections. Theoretically, this authority develops the Constitutional Court as the election court. According to this background, this article proposes a theoretical reflection over the Constitutional Court’s role as the election court. The main issue is theoretical reflection on judging. The theory is normative because it claims about what should the Constitutional Court do instead of what did the Constitutional Court do. As the principle, it suggests prudentiality first and judicial activism second. This theory is to criticize, and then to correct, the Constitutional Court practices as the election court in the past.


Download data is not yet available.


Barak, Aharon, The Judge in a Democracy (Princeton University Press 2006).
Bickel, Alexander M., The Least Dangerous Branch: The Supreme Court at the Bar of Politics (Yale University Press 1986).
Butt, Simon, The Constitutional Court and Democracy in Indonesia (Brill 2015).
Corwin, Edward S., The Constitution and What It Means Today (Princeton University Press 1978).
Hendrianto, Stefanus, Law and Politics of Constitutional Courts: Indonesia and the Search for Judicial Heroes (Routledge 2018).
Kurnia, Titon Slamet, Mahkamah Konstitusi Republik Indonesia: Sang Penjaga HAM (The Guardian of Human Rights) (Penerbit PT. Alumni 2013).
Anenson, T. Leigh, “Announcing the ‘Clean Hands’ Doctrine” (2018) 51 UC Davis Law Review 1827.
Barak, Aharon, “On Society, Law and Judging“ (2011) 47 Tulsa Law Review 297.
Bickel, Alexander M., “The Supreme Court 1960 Term: Foreword: Passive Virtues” (1961) 75 Harvard Law Review 40.
Butt, Simon, “The Constitutional Court and Indonesian Electoral Law” (2016) 16 Australian Journal of Asian Law 1.
Heise, Michael, “Brown v. Board of Education, Footnote 11, and Multidisciplinarity,” (2005) 90 Cornell Law Review 279.
Karlan, Pamela, “Judicial Independences” (2007) 95 Georgetown Law Journal 1041.
Reinstein, Robert J. & Mark C. Rahdert, “Reconstructing Marbury” (2005) 57 Arkansas Law Review 729.
Siregar, Fritz Edward, Indonesian Constitutional Politics 2003-2013 (SJD Thesis, The University of New South Wales 2016).
Wijaya, Pan Mohammad Faiz Kusuma, The Role of Constitutional Court in Securing Constitutional Government in Indonesia (Ph.D Thesis, The University of Queensland 2016).
How to Cite
Kurnia, T. (2019). MAHKAMAH KONSTITUSI SEBAGAI ELECTION COURT: REFLEKSI TEORETIS. Refleksi Hukum: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 3(1), 33-48.